THE SQUARE OF OPPOSITION
SYLLOGISTICS
Figures |
I. |
II. |
III. |
Major |
M-P |
S-M |
M-S |
Minor |
S-M |
P-M |
M-P |
Conclusion |
S-P |
S-P |
S-P |
NINETEEN
MODES OF THREE FIGURES
i. barbara celarent darii
ferio baralipton
celantes dabitis fapesmo frisesimorum
ii. cesare cambestres festino barocho iii. darapti
felapto disamis datisi bocardo ferison
Derivation rules: B, C, D, F indicate direction of reduction; prop. before
S is to be converted simply (terms simply swapped, valid: e, O); prop. before P to be converted per accidens, (terms
swapped, quantity changed, valid AÞI, EÞO); M
indicates transposition (order of premises changed); C indicates that
the mode is to be proved by reductio. Contraposition:
swap terms changing finite terms to infinite terms, valid: A, O.
Example: CESARE: ~$ S-M; " P-M Þ ~$
S-P /S=man, M=plant, P=oak/
Counterexample (ampliation): No dead are
alive and some men are dead; therefore, some men are not alive
Counterexample (topics): Socrates
is a man; therefore, Socrates is an animal
Counterexample (equivocation): Whatever is
healthy is alive; some medicine is healthy; therefore, etc.
Counterexample (quantification): A
man sees every donkey; Brunellus is a donkey; therefore, etc.